The documentary series Murder in Big Horn, which airs on Showtime and investigates the epidemic of missing and murdered Indigenous women, can only be described as equally haunting and powerful
Finally, it chronicles every aspect of several such cases, using not only first-hand accounts from those closest to them, but also archival footage to truly emphasize the seriousness of the situation.
Among the people appearing in this original are Henny Scott’s parents – Paula Castro-Stops and Nate Stops – so now if you’re interested in finding out more about them, you’ve come to the right place.
Also Read: Shacaiah Blue Harding: Is She Alive or Dead? Bio, street campaign, ex-boyfriend, missing person report
Henry Scott: Parents
Although Henny was born on January 9, 2004 to Apolonia “Paula” Castro-Stops and Charles Scott Jr., her stepfather Nathan “Nate” Stops was almost always a very important part of her life.
It is no surprise, then, that the member of the Crow tribe is referred to only as her sire/sire, a title he was undeniably proud of, alongside that of the Northern Cheyenne member’s partner at the time.
But sadly, their world turned upside down in mid-December 2018 when their 14-year-old daughter suddenly disappeared without a trace while hanging out with some older friends.
“The day Henny went missing … she called from a place of residence – the name had come up on the caller ID so I knew where she was,” Paula said candidly on the Showtime Original.
“It’s kind of like a party place where all the teenagers go to… hang out. There is no adult supervision. I told her, ‘You have to come home,’ and that was the last I heard from Henny.”
The fact that the teenager didn’t return came as a surprise to her friends and family alike, as she had agreed and prompted Nate to visit the property in genuine hopes of finding her.
That’s when Paula and Nate learned that their little girl had “walked” on the street by herself a long time ago and they had no choice but to quickly file a missing persons report with the sheriff’s office.
According to her account, however, the officers treated the duo like criminals instead of looking for Henny before claiming she’d probably made a boyfriend or was still somewhere at the party.
“We thought the police would be looking for her, but they really weren’t,” Nate explained. “There was no search, no Amber Alert, no nothing.”
The parents therefore decided to conduct their own search with the help of volunteers, only for the FBI to soon show up and find Heeny’s remains just 100 yards behind the aforementioned house.
Her cause of death was later ruled as hypothermia, but neither Paula nor Nate are convinced because she was allegedly not in her own clothes, no animals had caused any disturbance, although she appeared to have been dead outdoors for days, and she was bruised all over.
In fact, Nate claims investigators are “still not telling us [where her injuries came from]Why?”
Also Read: Kaysera from Pretty Places: How Did She Die? Age, Bio, Disappearance, Justice and more
Henny Scott’s parents: where are they now?
Although it’s been more than four years, Paula and Nate continue to wrestle with the mystery of what exactly happened to their little girl, all the while hoping for closure soon.
They desperately want a proper investigation into Henny’s case, or maybe even a clue as to how she ended up in someone else’s clothes behind the house when she went home alone.
They find some comfort in the fact that they have done (and are still doing) everything in their power to bring her true justice, but it’s not really the same.
Whether it was initially handing out flyers to find Henny, organizing the volunteer group, holding vigils, or going against their cultural beliefs to have her body exhumed, Paula and Nate have done it all.
It hasn’t made a difference yet, but residents of Lame Deer, Montana, continue to hope that someday it will — until then (and even beyond) they will keep their daughter alive in their hearts.
We should mention that Paula, an emergency medical technician (EMT) with the Northern Cheyenne Ambulance Service, appears to be no longer involved with Nate.
The latter is apparently currently serving a two-year sentence for having sexual relations with a minor when she was 14 to 16; He pled guilty to a single charge of molestation in September 2022.
Henny Scott, a 14-year-old Native American girl, went missing in mid-December 2018 while staying with friends. She was found dead two weeks later on the Northern Cheyenne Reservation near Lame Deer, Montana.
Her death is one of the unsolved cases that former Los Angeles District Attorney Loni Coombs investigates on the Oxygen special Murdered and Missing in Montana.
Henny Scott: Who Killed Her?
A coroner determined that Scott died of hypothermia and that the manner of death was accidental, but her devastated parents, Nate and Paula Stops, are still grappling with a haunting mystery.
What happened to your beloved daughter between her disappearance and the time she was found?
The crisis of the murdered and missing indigenous women is explained in more detail here.
The two-hour special on oxygen sheds an unsettling light on the context of her question. According to the US Department of Justice, the murder rate of Native American girls is ten times the national average, and one Native American girl goes missing every eight hours in the United States.
The results of the forensic investigation into the death of Scott’s parents’ daughter have been questioned.
According to a report on kulr8.com, after a search party organized by the tribe discovered the girl’s body, they believed the girl had “bruise and a broken nose.”
According to the Murdered and Missing in Montana report, Nate and Paula Stops went against the cultural beliefs of the Northern Cheyenne Indian tribe and had their daughter’s body exhumed for a second examination to determine if her child sustained any injuries that was committed at the time not discovered at first autopsy.
Henny Scott: Bio
Henny Scott Scott’s body was taken to the Westmoreland County Forensics Center in Greensburg, Pennsylvania, where it is currently being processed. According to Coombs, the autopsy was performed by a forensic pathologist named Dr. Cyril Wecht and a coroner named Patricia Ross.
Despite the possibility that Scott was exposed to the elements for an extended period of time, examination found no signs of animal or insect bites on her body.
Wecht also found no signs of blunt force trauma in the body. He informed Nate and Paula Stops that there was no fracture of the nasal bone or nasal cartilage. “There was no broken nose,” he said. “X-ray examinations were also carried out, the results of which show no fractures.”
A woman with a Rose Kuehni Spd 2815 shoots her boyfriend, places his body in a box, then has her lover throw the box off a cliff.
Wecht also found no bruises. He attributed the suspected discoloration to the pooling of blood from gravity following Scott’s death. As with the initial investigation, he found no traces of drugs on Scott’s body and he found no evidence of sexual assault or intercourse.
“I found no evidence of foul play,” Wecht said, although he admitted he was puzzled by the details of the case.
“I don’t know what type of search was conducted,” he said. “She was only 200 meters from where she had been. I wonder why it took 21 days to find her… It’s possible she may have died somewhere else. I have no explanation as to what would have caused her death.”
Though the Stops are still wondering how their daughter died alone so close to a house for weeks without being discovered, Coombs says they were comforted to learn some details from the autopsy, such as there was no evidence that that she was raped. They still vow to find out exactly what happened to Henny that night.
Henny Scott: Cause of Death
- The Big Horn County coroner said a 14-year-old Busby girl whose body was found on the Northern Cheyenne Reservation near Lame Deer in December died of hypothermia.
- Coroner Terry Bullis said an autopsy confirmed Henny Scott died of hypothermia, with alcohol in her system contributing. The way was random.
- In late December, Northern Cheyenne Tribe Vice President Conrad Fisher and FBI forensic investigators notified the family of Scott’s death.
- At the time, authorities issued a missing person’s report for Scott, believing she was on her way to Hardin’s and injured.
- The deliberation was later called off without finding Scott.
- Just days later, a search party organized by the tribe searched for Scott and found her body.
Also read: Luella Brien: who is she? Bio, Careers, Apsáalooke Tribe, Facts and More